TFW2005
Hisstank
Thundercats
TokuNation
Toyark
Home
News
Garo
Godzilla
Kamen Rider
Metal Heroes
Power Rangers
Super Sentai
Ultraman
All News Categories
Forum
News & Rumors
Power Rangers
Kamen Rider
Super Sentai
Other Toku Series
Toys and Collectables
Marketplace
Creative
Galleries
Companies
Bandai Japan
Tamashii Nations
Saban Brands
Bandai America
Toei
Characters
Kamen Rider Ghost
Kamen Rider Specter
Kamen Rider Necrom
Mighty Morphin Green Ranger
Dino Charge Red Ranger
Toylines
S.H. Figuarts
S.H. MonsterArts
DX Mecha
Megazords
Legacy
Shows
Kamen Rider Ghost
Doubutsu Sentai Zyuohger
Power Rangers Dino Supercharge
Power Rangers Movie 2017
TokuNation.com
>
TokuNation
Integration
User Name
Remember Me?
Password
Rules
Register
Community
Today's Posts
Search
Community Links
Members List
Search Forums
Show Threads
Show Posts
Advanced Search
Go to Page...
Thread
:
Kamen Rider Die watches Kamen Rider Hibiki
View Single Post
10-24-2020, 12:15 PM
#
379
Kamen Rider Die
Kamen Ride Or Die
Join Date: Aug 2019
Location: Chicago, IL
Posts: 6,159
You guys! Thank you so much for sharing your thoughts on the first phase of Hibiki! (Or, for Switchblade's benefit, the
true
phase of Hibiki.) Someday I'm going to figure out how to actually be awake when these posts are coming in (what if people who wanted to talk about Hibiki lived in my country or slept at night), but in the meantime, let me have this pleasant afternoon of responding to a page of Hibiki thoughts. It's a fitting tribute to this exiting era!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
FreshToku
I do wonder, had this show been the way it was, but the toys were all cool transforming and beeping devices like the ones in Faiz, maybe everything would have turned out okay for the production team after all? Not that it matters, with the unique direction and story choices that purposefully treat the superhero action as mundane as possibly, mixed with the so-and-so merchandise, I wasn't surprised at all to hear that the show didn't exactly sell well nor did it appeal to the average Rider fan. It's great to see you receiving the show well, though I totally get how it must have been somewhat surreal and even disappointing at parts in how it disregards the typical tokusatsu tropes that is expected.
I think one of the most valuable parts of Hibiki is, maybe, showing how far you can stretch the Kamen Rider formula/franchise? This show's
stunningly
well-made, but it pushes itself way too far outside the boundaries of what you can get away with on a show designed to sell toys to Japanese children.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
FreshToku
However, barring all that, it's a real shame that Hibiki wasn't allowed to keep hitting it's own beat. I'd be saying that even if I didn't like the show, since I think it's always great when ambitious or creative visions take precedence over being easy to sell. That just doesn't or can't happen in this franchise anymore. ...Well, I mean, it couldn't happen to too far a degree back in 2005 either since yeah, everyone got fired for this show, but still.
Even though I agree with you, and would've preferred the main team got to see their story through, there's only so much I'm going to feel like the creators got robbed. I mean, this was not the first Kamen Rider show of all-time; there's an expectation and a mandate and probably financial benchmarks. If they were either delusional enough to think things were going to magically turn around or stubborn enough to not care... maybe they're lucky they got 29 episodes!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
FreshToku
But, oh well. Even if I wish for more variety in style and stories in Kamen Rider, I still stick with it because clearly this formula they have and will continue milking for decades is something that appeals to me.
Yeah, I... this show maybe made me appreciate the formula a little more? I'm not sure that's the sort of praise they want, though!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
FreshToku
Have fun with the movie! I hope you specifically watch the Director's Cut which has a slightly longer runtime because it has a few extra scenes here and there.
Hmm. The thing is, I've got the Director's Cut in standard def, and the Theatrical Cut in hi-def. I'm not sure which one I'll watch tonight. If anyone else has a take on this, let me know!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Switchblade
I can see where you're coming from, Die. I don't have the same take on the show, but I get it. I love that they went for something different here and I actually quite like the action scenes. The giant CGI monster fights are very much limited by 2005 kid's TV show budget CGI, but I still think we get some good action scenes. Of course, at the end of the day I'm here for Hibiki and Asumu's relationship and the warm feelings of being with this cast of characters that I love. I'm fine with the show not having as much focus on the monster fighting because goddamn is this some good steakhouse chicken.
Honestly, the budgetary stuff like the CGI... as much as I might rag on it or call it out, it's not even in the Top 20 of problems I might've had with the show. It's janky (one time embarrassingly so), but it's a TV budget from 2005. I can make allowances!
It's more that the fights and action feel so impersonal, so characterless. One of my early-Heisei complaints, coming out of Phase 2, was that there's no chatter with the villains, that they're all growling monsters. Hibiki takes that and says But What If They Were Also Gigantic And Had No Personality. Like, there're the Douji and Hime, but we're usually lucky to get one scene with both of them before they get partially or completely detonated.
For me, I need to feel like a Kamen Rider is fighting
someone
, not just
fighting
. I didn't really get that out of Hibiki's action scenes.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Switchblade
I think one of the biggest tragedies about what happened with Hibiki is that it brought the really experimental part of the early Heisei era to an end. Kabuto is a much more conventional Rider show and after that we got Den-O, which was such a big hit that almost every show that came after it would copy a lot of its elements. We wouldn't get a show that really tried anything radically different again until Gaim. I love so many of the shows that came after this, but I can't help but wonder how things might have been different if Toei were still more willing to experiment with the show.
Yeah, maybe! As much as this part of Hibiki has made me appreciate some of the guard-rails in the Kamen Rider franchise, it could've been fun if this all got to be a little more unique and unexpected as time went on.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Switchblade
And I'm glad catwhowalks brought up Daimajin Kanon. It's very much the spiritual sequel to Hibiki and is absolutely delightful in many of the same ways. You also get a lot of catharsis from it, as the core plot is about a young woman who's dealing with depression after a deeply personal creative work gets stolen from her and crassly commercialized.
Sound like something I'd really enjoy! I look forward to checking it out in 2025!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Switchblade
I'll also join FreshToku in hoping you enjoy the movie. I think it's one of the more fun movies from this era, even if its inspirations are kind of obvious.
It's going to be a fun movie night, I'm guessing!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Sunred
In case this was not further explained, here I go. Onis of Takeshi primarily tend to have names where their oni name and real name's first syllables are all the same. For example:
Hi
biki >
Hi
toshi
Hi
daka
I
buki >
I
ori
I
zumi
To
doriki >
To
mizo
To
dayama
Za
nki >
Za
omaru
Za
itsuhara
Also,
Da
nki >
Da
isuke
Da
nda
Another fun fact, Hibiki's suit actor and primary "nigo rider" actor during the first batch of Heisei rider shows, has retired some time ago and is now a judo therapist.
Very cool! Thanks!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kurona
I'm glad you enjoyed it Die, and it's definitely interesting to see your perspective on this. I guess if I was to take your metaphor and say why I like it despite that... maybe it would have been better to go for a Chicken place to begin with, but often I'm not too fond of Chicken places; and the atmosphere and trappings of a steak house are not just what allured me to this one to begin with but also make it a lot more unique. Though it also definitely helps that I like the steak here a fair bit more than you!
Sure! There's a real element of I Can't Believe You're Trying This And I Can't Believe It's Working that helps add an addictive flavor to Hibiki's early episodes, one that keeps you hooked even when the more traditional parts come up short. If someone was feeling burned out or let down by shows like Blade or Faiz (how dare), I can see where Hibiki would feel like a pleasant alternative.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kurona
I haven't been talking much due to a lot of things happening otherwise and my laptop only coming in this week; and it takes a while for me to get my thoughts down. So maybe expect some Hibiki 1-29 posts on the 30-47 portion, weirdly enough? I promise that's not out of spite of that second half!
Promise!
Though I'll definitely have some things to say about at least 30 and 47 themselves.
I look forward to it, even if you'll have to remind me of basically everything that happened in an episode I watched last week. I do not retain this stuff very well.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kurona
All in all the first half of Hibiki is an experience that I think is super understated in Rider whether it's something one likes or not -- you won't find anything else like it, even moreso than W or Kuuga; and it's a good watch for any Rider fan. Here's hoping you'll join Andro in the ranks of one of the few people who likes the next batch!
Even if I unequivocally adored the first part of Hibiki... I mean,
Inoue
. There's almost no chance I dislike the Inoue part.
...right?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Fish Sandwich
Okay I'm maybe not good with metaphors, but my point is that I will always appreciate a show like Hibiki that's clearly trying to be this well-rounded work that holds value to a wide range of people. Dropping the figurative speech for a bit, I've always been obsessed with "steak", and a big part of that is how flexible I feel stories with superheroes or otherwise colorful characters can be. I love seeing them dip their toes into all kinds of genres and using those larger than life elements to complement the narrative in a way less fantastic stories simply aren't capable of. A tale about a teacher questioning the worth of his job carries a lot more impact when the worth turns out to be the hero saving the city from monsters on a weekly basis, yeah?
And, uh, as you can maybe tell from the fact the example I just pulled was from Kuuga, I'm honestly not the best person to stick up for Hibiki. Sometimes there are shows I
respect
a lot more than I
like
, and Hibiki is exactly that. Mind you, I'm judging that within the standard of how much I already like Kamen Rider; I absolutely like this show a whole lot! And I certainly have my attachment to it. But while rewatching it was loads of fun, and I think I do have a deeper appreciation for what it was doing now than I used to, there's a simple truth about my feelings towards the show I kept coming back to:
Hibiki just doesn't resonate with me all that much.
...admittedly I might've only been thinking that so often because it makes for a good pun in Japanese. (心に響かないという) But, I don't know, there's like this invisible barrier between me and the show or something. Despite everything, it doesn't stick with me the same way so many other Rider shows do. I have a few theories as to why. The big glaring one is that, as I've mentioned in a few places, finales are keys to me (just look at Blade!), and Hibiki didn't get to have one of those the way it wanted to. For all I know, the best was yet to come, and the "true" version of this show would've been special to me the same way something like Kuuga or Ghost is.
But obviously we'll never quite know, and, yeah, it's both a huge shame and also not hard to see why things went the way they did. I've actually probably got one of the more generous outlooks on the next era of this series (maybe?), though, and while I don't like to say these things upfront, I think there's a more than good chance you won't feel the need to retire the phrase "Inoue forever" when all is said and done. So despite all this doom and gloom, I don't think it's exactly all downhill from here.
This is maybe coming close to something I was thinking about last night (hi I never stop thinking about Kamen Rider), and that's the fact that Hibiki opted to make the subtext (how does a boy become a man, and how do you raise a child) into text (the Asumu/Hibiki storyline) maybe robbed it of the metaphorical and allegorical tools a Kamen Rider show needs to thrive?
Without Asumu being an early-20s Oni trainee, and without Hibiki being his official mentor, it doesn't leave the show a lot of ways to express an episode's themes in more dynamic, sci-fi superhero ways. It largely just creates two separate piles: Story and Action. It'll rhyme them, a bit, but it's always clear that the Story is happening to and with people, while the action is happening to and with monsters and Oni.
Like, I don't want to tell anyone how to fix a show that went off the air over a decade before I started watching Kamen Rider, but:
Zanki and Todoroki
. That's the
maybe
more successful, more superhero-y version of Asumu and Hibiki. That's where you can tell metaphorical stories about the difficulties of growing up, of being a good parent, but doing it within the framework of a Kamen Rider show. Is it as special or unique as the Asumu/Hibiki stuff? Definitely not. Would it've been more fun to watch? Possibly!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
DreamSword
I don't feel like I can really add anything to this outside of what anyone else said, so I'll just go ahead and say that the first half of Hibiki really highlights something that makes Phase 1 Heisei my favorite era of Kamen Rider overall: The willingness to experiment and the drive to make (almost) every show really unique. Granted, I'm only halfway through Showa and like a third through Phase 2 Heisei, but it seems like that era more than the others tried the hardest to have every season stand out from the rest, and it's a shame that the series would lose that once the era closed.
Yeah, the formula... Like I've mentioned, Hibiki's lack of it maybe hurt some of its momentum, but it's not like a strict adherence to it saved a bunch of Phase 2 shows. Wizard, man, that is a show that locks into the formula to the exclusion of all else, and it can be a grind. I think it pays off in the ending (your mileage may vary), but it makes for a
rough
middle section.
__________________
Currently working on: Go-Busters is next! Archive of previous shows on
KamenRiderDie.com
!
Kamen Rider Die
View Public Profile
Send a private message to Kamen Rider Die
Find More Posts by Kamen Rider Die
TokuNation News & Rumors
Alternative Cut of "Day Of The Dumpster" Released
Shodo SUPER Kyoryuger Teaser
Figuarts/Seihou GRIDMAN
SH Figuarts BoonBoomger Red
Hasbro Licenses Power Rangers Toys to Playmates Toys
More New Posts
What are you watching? (Kamen Rider Edition)
S.H. Figuarts (Toku Related) Thread
Kamen Rider Gotchard Episode 34- "Only One! All Roads Lead To Gorgeousness!"
Kamen Rider Gotchard Episode 33- "Legend Rider? 100 Years Too Early!" Discussion
How is Everyone Today- New
DreamSword Watches Unfamiliar Toku: Part 1 - GARO
Super Sentai minipla appreciation thread!
Funny Toku Images thread
DreamSword Rereads the Power Rangers Comics
Recent Purchases: April 2024
Current Poll
How Would You Rate This Episode?
Excellent!
Good
Average
OK
Poor...
»
View Poll Results
»
Comment On This Poll
»
This Poll Has 0 Replies
Search Forums
»
Advanced Search
All times are GMT -5. The time now is
05:49 PM
.
Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Powered by
vBadvanced
CMPS