|
Community Links |
Members List |
Search Forums |
Advanced Search |
Go to Page... |
![]() |
Quote:
EDITED TO ADD: hey what if i talked about why First of all, I love that the only reason she became a secretary is because she wanted to be a journalist and accidentally took classes to become a secretary instead. That concept, of her tripping and falling into a completely different career and her being, like, *shrug emoji*... perfect. Gold-plated perfection. I don't know if I've ever heard of a better origin story. But, for the mix of Ore Journal, she's just the right kind of weirdo to level up the dynamic. Dedicated, but sloppy. Manipulative, but scatterbrained. Earnest, but untrustworthy. And she immediately creates an entertaining rivalry (unknowingly, because: Megumi) with Shimada. It's a great time for more Ore Journal scenes, which is something I'm not sure I expected to ever say and mean. |
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
https://media.discordapp.net/attachm...7560/block.png Quote:
https://media.discordapp.net/attachm...4/grandma2.jpghttps://media.discordapp.net/attachm...28/grandma.png How about Yui with long hair instead? https://media.discordapp.net/attachm...31611689/g.jpg Quote:
|
Quote:
I think it's a little different, though. One, in that previous episode a Mirror Mmonster was able to grab the entire contents of train car in a fraction of a second and in total silence. Here, it takes three monsters to pick off a few people in a room, and it usually takes them long enough for folks to scream and the heroes to race to get there. Plus, having not seen the first boat attack, I'd just assume that the monsters took their time in grabbing humans. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
I'm going to defend Okubo's hiring policies. I like that this dude took in the abrasive reporters and neophyte photojournalists and socially-awkward IT managers and clumsy office workers and made them all a workplace family. I don't know if any of these people could stay employed under anyone else. (Reiko's a great reporter, but she's terrible at following instructions and mostly disrespectful to her boss, and that ain't gonna fly at a lot of companies.) I think it's cool that Okubo takes the dregs and says I Can Make This Work, I Can Make Them Great, They Also Probably Aren't Aware How Much I'm Under-Paying Them. |
I like how you've gone from thinking Yui seems pretty interesting, to thinking the show needs to do more with her, to thinking she's pathetic, to thinking the show's using her a bit better, to now just thinking she has nice hair.
That's the kind of critique that makes these threads special. It's like if you take time to blink, Die will already have a completely new wildly different hot take on Yui. :lol |
Quote:
|
Quote:
https://kamenriderdie.com/images/kr/...egoodhair1.png https://kamenriderdie.com/images/kr/...egoodhair2.png https://kamenriderdie.com/images/kr/...egoodhair3.png (Also, it's a total accident, but I maybe could not have picked a more representative image for my thoughts on Yui than her looking confused and saying "What happened to you?") My main thing is that I never want to be unfair with these threads. If I dislike a show and it does something good, I want to call it out. If I like a show and it does something bad, I want to call it out. Yui's character has, for me, been remarkably inconsistent (her only scene this episode is thinking about her brother and watching Ren go do hero stuff!!!), but her hair was on-point this episode, and I wanted to compliment it. I would love to have a consistent take on her, but the show would need to have one first. Quote:
|
MASKED RIDER RYUKI EPISODE 32
https://kamenriderdie.com/images/kr/ryuki/ryuki32a.png I feel like this is the best kind of story you can do to deepen Asakura's character. Let other people try and divine his motivations, let them project their biases onto him, but never really nail down what he's thinking. The more mysterious you can make Asakura, I think the better he plays. Mika's certain he's a good guy, Ren's certain he's a villain, and Shinji is the audience, wanting to believe he can change but knowing he probably won't. It's tricky, to find that balance. In the Asakura's Brother story, the show veered too far into having the heroes be trusting dopes. In this one, there's circumstantial evidence that Asakura didn't hurt anyone on the boat, that he protected Mika with no ulterior motive, but he never really defends himself or explains his actions. (I mean, there's the bit at the end where he says Mika was just his hostage, but it's not real convincing.) It makes him complicated, in a dramatically compelling way. Having a complete redemption story for Asakura, I feel like it'd ruin his character the same as keeping him a maniacal killer. This middle ground where maybe, under exceptionally heightened circumstances, Asakura might have a sliver of empathy inside of him... I think it's the smartest way to evolve his character. It's funny, to lead this write-up off by talking about Asakura, because in opposition to last episode's It's About Asakura Even If He's Not In It story, Asakura's all over this one, and yet it's not really about him. It's about what he represents. He's a killer, and an unrepentant one at that. He's a monster, and there's no restraining him. The longer he's free, the more innocents are at risk. He's made his bed of surrounding himself with hungry monsters, and now he gets to lie in it. It's justice, by nearly anyone's definition. But. But Mika cares for him. Mika needs him in her life. She needs him to exist in the world. Asakura's death would hurt her. His death would make someone's life, even if it's only one person's life, worse. And that means he deserves to live, same as anyone. The loss of a life isn't just about the person who dies, it's about the people they loved, the world they inhabited. Asakura has earned his fate, but he deserves to live. Not for himself, but for the people who care about him. It's a sweet message, and one only Shinji could properly articulate. It's hard to give a speech advocating for the continued existence of a man who just had his brother devoured by a monster, but the actor's performance and the beautiful spring There Is Beauty After Rain montage really sells the necessity of saving Asakura. It's a monumental ask of the audience, but I was like, Yeah, Shinji should save him. That's the crux of the episode, a make-or-break point for the story, and I thought they landed it gracefully. I sort-of wish that was all that was in this episode? The last one gained points for staying pretty laser-focused on the boat story, while I felt like this one lost points for trying to serve other plots. There are a few scenes of Reiko investigating what happened to Shiro in America, and I found it typically dull. One, I can't believe that, after Tezuka's death, someone else has hijacked Yui's only plotline. Hilarious! This show! Second, I just don't care about the small amounts of information Reiko gets about Mirror Worlds and Secret Science Societies and things that viewers have known about for 30+ episodes. It's so boring to me, watching her catch up to the rest of the show. If this was shocking information that changed what we knew about Shiro and Rider Battles, I'd be into it. But, like, she's just learning the plot of Masked Rider Ryuki. I already know that! I've been watching that for 32 episodes! That part was a bummer, but the rest of this episode was a surprisingly sweet story about the ways even the worst people have value, and can enrich other lives. A real pleasant episode. https://kamenriderdie.com/images/kr/ryuki/ryuki32b.png |
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Ryuki's setup really does excel at bringing the concepts of its world, the heroism and the danger, into the home. Kuuga and Agito have monsters that are out there in the world, and later series would have allegorical monsters that take advantage of needs and desires, but Ryuki made sure that their monsters are coming from inside the house. Kids who like to be scared (which is to say most kids in Kamen Rider's target demographic) could pretend that there was a monster hiding in a hallway mirror, or a turned-off TV, and do a quick Henshin to pretend they were in there with them, battling to protect their family. It's a smart construction, to make the danger more universal. |
This episode in particular has always stuck out to me, I think. Even if you don't entirely agree with Shinji on going out of his way to save Asakura's life (which I'm pretty sure is everybody), you understand why it's important for him to do this. If he hadn't saved Asakura, regardless of whether you think it's right or wrong, it just wouldn't be Shinji.
That said, and this is not really relevant, I really wish dragon man could give snake man a beat-down. It's an action show after all, and I think at this point of the show when I was first watching, I was thinking to myself 'gosh, our main character has not really had a good showing against anyone who is not a mirror monster'. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Quote:
But other than that, remember when you were freaking out about how OP Asakura is (but Ren also has Survive!)? This episode now explains the drawback of pulling the stunt Asakura did, he has 3 monsters not only to battle, but also to feed. He has to work 3 times the other Rider does to feed them, or he'll be eaten by one of them, especially Evildiver and Metalgelas still seeking vengeance for their masters. And like you being ok with Kitaoka torture, I like watching Asakura suffer, like when Knight Survive curbstomps him before, and when Kitaoka gloats to him here about his impending doom where he'll be killed by his own monsters. If Asakura truly dies by that it'll be an interesting means to end him IMO; gaining more power, only to be killed by that act. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
https://media.discordapp.net/attachm...y_to_Topic.png https://challengerscomics.com/images...i/ryuki27d.png |
Quote:
Also, killing the monsters would be a cool feat… if the show gave them anything more than wild beasts with poorly defined origins and no motivation. Especially coming between two well-handled groups with very clear motives. The fact that the show still insists on using them long past their ability to generate drama just diminishes their significance. |
Quote:
On the one hand, that's just not the story they're trying to tell. They're trying to tell a story about a warrior who doesn't want to fight other warriors. Having Shinji get into a brawl with Asakura, especially in this episode... it'd break the show. It would make the show about nothing. On the other hand, though, I think it's fair to ask Is That A Story Worth Telling. For some people, that's going to be a Yes, for some people, a No. I'm not sure there's anything wrong with saying you don't have an interest in the story that's being told, or that you wish they'd have told a different story. It's not weird to look at a superhero action show and want to see the superheroes fight. It's just, this one's about why they shouldn't fight, or why fighting isn't the best solution. Doing something that subverts the audience's expectations, it's going to make people love it or hate it. Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
The Shinji stuff... not sure I'm seeing that at all. I think a lot of what like about Shinji's character in this show, and the dynamic as a whole, is how much he's challenged, morally and ethically, by the other Riders. On other shows, Ghost in particular, it was a little frustrating for me how quickly some adversarial relationships would, after one story, realign as Ghost Knows Best. It seemed like a waste, to take that friction and replace it with falling in line, easy acceptance. With this show, I like how Shinji doesn't get a pass just because he's the main character, how the other Riders get to keep their own viewpoints, how the world of the show is designed to make Shinji's choices more difficult. And, man, I feel like Shinji's worldview has evolved a lot? If anything, there've been times where I feel like it's switched around too much. He's always going to be a guy who thinks he knows best and jumps in without considering the consequences. But all that "shitting on" Shinji the show does, I like it because it forces him to refine his arguments, consider other perspectives, look beyond his own experiences. It's never going to flip him 180 into a ruthless fighter, but we've seen how Shinji's morals meet the reality of Rider Battles, and I've liked the story that's come out of that. And the monster thing... I don't love it. It's not my favorite type of monster, where they're just beasts. But, with 13 Riders to tell stories with, it's maybe better that show doesn't also try to tell stories with the monsters? That might make for an overstuffed series. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
https://media.discordapp.net/attachm...63028/bait.png And isn't Asakura's motivation pretty clear? He simply wants to feed all Venosnaker, Evildiver, and Metalgelas at once to survive, and Buzzstingers, which is a pack of 3 monsters is the way to feed all of them simultaneously, as feeding only one of them will have him get eaten by the other 2. Quote:
|
Quote:
To me, it feels like some gray area. Not saying you're wrong, but I don't think there's a definitive answer to be had on this one. Quote:
(Thanks to Kurona for bringing this up. If anyone feels like things are getting too heated and/or unconstructive, please don't be shy about citing it!) One of my feelings about discussing art is that you can't really change anyone's mind. If someone doesn't enjoy a piece of art, all of the explanations and clarifications in the world aren't going to make them like it. Similarly, if someone loves a piece of art, telling them all of the reasons why it's bad is at best unhelpful, and at worse, kind-of a jerky thing to do. The best we can all do in discussing art is explaining our perspective, and respecting other people's perspectives. It's fun to talk about these shows. It's fun to say what you liked, what you didn't like, and get into debates about why something did or didn't work. But when you start getting upset at the way someone else views art, just keep in mind that they feel as strongly about this franchise as you do, even when you see things differently. It's okay to disagree, and it's fun to debate, but let's please all stay friendly about it. We're all Kamen Rider fans, and we're allowed to get different things out of Kamen Rider shows. |
MASKED RIDER RYUKI EPISODE 33
https://kamenriderdie.com/images/kr/ryuki/ryuki33a.png Not really a lot to this one, structurally. There's, like, one main plot, and a half-dozen build-ups for other plots. Let's see if I can remember them all! The main plot, it's paying off the cliffhanger from last episode. (I don't usually like talking about the cliffhangers. There's generally not much more to talk about than speculation, and I never know how prominent some of them will be. Sometimes I get really excited and the next episode completely blows it off. I'd rather wait until there's some substance.) Megumi's seen Shinji walk out of a mirror, and now she's going to investigate. It's a fun story, slightly humorous and sort-of low stakes. Technically, there's a chance that Megumi could crack this thing wide open (a chance), or Shinji could unburden himself and tell his friends he fights monsters inside of mirrors with the help of Ren, escaped convict Asakura, and the worst person they know, but I didn't really think the status quo was going to change that much. Sure enough, while Megumi's dogged perseverance (she's not terrible at her job!) does keep Shinji from finishing off a monster, she gets the wrong idea and declares his previous mirror activities to be that of an illusionist. ~sad trombone~ Shinji dodges a bullet, Princess Megumi puts on an ornate demonstration, and everything goes back to normal for the crew of Ore Journal. Except it doesn't, because Megumi's ludicrous demonstration (I hope she just rented that disappearing box) is the final piece that Reiko needs to complete a working theory on the last eight months worth of mysterious disappearances: a mirror world. On the one hand, I've expressed my disappointment that so much time has been spent on Reiko learning stuff the audience has known for a while. Dramatically, it's not that exciting. In this one, I think it kind-of works, and not just because of Reiko's new haircut. (It looks great! It's so weird that she got a haircut because I feel like that usually doesn't happen during a series? It seems like every dude's hair is a foot longer by the end of the season, anyway.) The nuts and bolts of investigative journalism are... not exactly something this show has made a priority. It's nice when it happens, but oftentimes it's left to the margins. Giving it a little room to breathe, seeing Reiko take a half-season's worth of clues and then, during a goddamn magic act, figure out that final piece of the puzzle, it works pretty well. I'm not sure it makes up for all of those scenes where we knew what she didn't, but I liked how the two main plots (calling this a main plot isn't entirely accurate, but I guess I just spent as long talking about this one as the actual main plot, so maybe there's more than one after all) in this one connected. Smart writing. Most of the rest of this one is just Shiro being an asshole and tightening the screws on everyone. The scene where he visits Kitaoka and basically says Fight or Die while raising his eyebrows as high as he can on the word DIE, it's still funny to me. I love the weird salesmanship of Shiro, how he's so eager to get Riders fighting, how he fundamentally doesn't understand why they aren't murdering each other by the end of this sentence. It's cute, in a socially awkward way. He's got a passion for superpowered men murdering each other, and he really wants to share that passion, you know? He's a very enthusiastic instigator of battles to the death. It's adorable. I mean, less adorable when he almost kills Eri to motivate Ren, and Yui's whole Time Has Run Out In The Mirror World-esque dissipating doesn't seem like a good thing, also Asakura is maybe going to try and pick off a near-death Kitaoka... okay, I think “adorable” might've been too far. I see that now. https://kamenriderdie.com/images/kr/ryuki/ryuki33b.png |
Oh, also also also.
Not on topic, but I've gotten pretty deep into SO-DO collecting the last few months, and I've ended up with some extra boxes. I'd rather these find a good home than get any money out of 'em, so I'm letting them go for free as long as folks pay shipping. (I mean, technically it's "pay-what-you-can", so if you feel like kicking in a few bucks you can, but I'm totally fine with them just going out the door.) Some stuff's been grabbed, but there're a couple good ones left. If you've wanted to try out SO-DO, or just need a little distraction right now, see if there's anything you want over in this post! |
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
Well since we have a new entry into the Rider War, I think it’s alright for me to share this bit of trivia. He’s the last new addition to the action figure line that came out with this series. All that’s left are repaints of Ryuki. I’ve tried adding a picture to demonstrate, but I’m not sure if it’s shown up. So I’ll post the link just in case.
https://vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/...20180804030414 http://https://vignette.wikia.nocook...20180804030414 |
Quote:
Also, GODDAMN KAMEN RIDER AND ITS GODDAMN SPECIALS. I was just about to watch the 13 Riders special, since it debuted between episodes 33 and 34, and I like to watch this stuff as close to release order as possible. But SCENE ONE is a dying Ren handing his Card Deck to Shinji, and Shinji turning into Knight Survive, and WHAT THE HELL DID I JUST WANDER INTO? Can I watch this thing now, or what? Is this supposed to be watched way later in the show? The Wiki describes it as both a "prologue" and "an alternate telling", and, like, WHAT?! Just, can I watch this thing now without ruining anything? Anybody? |
I promise that 13 Riders isn't going to affect anything if you watch it now. (I mean, otherwise it would be ruining the show for all the people who watched it back when it aired.)
|
Well, I guess there are spoilers only for like, suits that will appear later. If that's something you mind, then that's one reason to avoid it.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
save it for the end, it should be the last thing you watch.
|
Quote:
|
I didn't mention this earlier because I kind of thought it would be nagging, but both 13 Riders and the movie are best saved for after the show in my opinion. Both are alternate takes on Ryuki's story that exist completely independent of the series proper.
I don't think it'll ruin the show or anything if you want to stick close to air-dates like you always do, but just remember this isn't Ex-Aid. Extraneous side material isn't deeply tied to the canon yet. |
Quote:
|
13 Riders is best watched after absorbing all Ryuki medias. Yeah it's independent to the main series, and you'll know why after completing Ryuki.
Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Hey, everybody.
Thanks so much for the feedback on 13 Riders and when to watch it. It's a way more loaded question than I'd thought? I appreciate you all trying to describe it without ruining anything, which it seems like is pretty tricky for this one. There's some definite pros and cons for each option of when's a good time to watch it, but I think I'm going to try and stick to its original airdate of between 33 and 34. I just like watching this stuff the way a fan would've back then, you know? Get that authentic Kamen Rider experience, or a close approximation. The problem is, my window for watching stuff wasn't super huge, and in the meantime of trying to sort this out I pretty much used it up watching this week's oversized Better Call Saul. (KIM! KIM FOREVER! Holy shit do I want to talk about what they did with her character in this one!) Looks like 13 Riders is going to have to be an after-work thing today, a little later in the afternoon. Thanks for everyone's help! Trying to piece together a Proper Viewing Order for this franchise... they don't make it easy! Quote:
|
Quote:
|
The only canon is the Ryuki 2-parter in Decade because it's the only version that makes sense send tweet.
|
Yeah, I would say until Den-O, every single bit of extra-series stuff whether it be movies or HBVs or whatever is fine to just watch after you've finished.
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:56 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:56 AM.
|