In the one where it was actually an enjoyable show with good fights and likable characters?

I liked Mystic Force. Maybe not the best Disney season, but easily the best Kalish one, even if it was full of his standard tropes. I liked the suits, I liked the story, and it had some great characters (Xander was fantastic and I absolutely loved Vida). The show did get way too Nick-centric at times and the "I believe in magic" ending was kinda bullshit, but on the whole I really liked the show.

Yeah. Pity she never did anything. :(

And which characters?

Cyber-Cam was an idiotic premise.
Lothor's evil plot starts with turning Sensei into a Guinea Pig!
Marah and Kapri were eye-rollingly idiotic. (Still can't believe they brought her back for Dino-Force either)
Choobo, Zurgane, and Motodrome were just poor excuses for Generals.

And that whole story where the girl is a species that changes every 24 hours, and of course Shane falls for her, before she gives him the Battilzer with the Bounty Hunter coming after her... How was that ever a good idea?!

Of course Mystic Force went Nick-Heavy sometimes, almost every MMPR season goes Red Ranger heavy. Even Samurai is having that happen now and again.

And better villians. Octomus, Morticon, Necrolai! Who didn't love Necrolai? And Koragg. I'm sorry but Koragg alone puts alot of Ninja Storm to shame.

And Bullshit to I Believe in Magic? Way to be literal with the material. It wasn't just Magic that brought back their powers at the end, it was the Faith of the people of the forest and the city. Coming together. That brought the Rangers back again. Faith in themselves, in the Rangers, in each other. It was a good message. ... NInja Storm... Next you'll tell me that Jay Leno clone Genie in Big Bad Beetleborgs was excellent character design. -flails-

Other than the fact I haven't watched OO yet and I'd place Ninja Storm waaaaay down the bottom, I'm pretty much in agreement with your rankings. I might rate SPD slightly higher than Mystic Force, but they're pretty much on par with each other.