I have no animosity towards Power Rangers Turbo. This is because I only saw the movie. As such, I do not have an opinion on T.J., since almost everything I know about him comes from History of Power Rangers. I have, however, watched RPM, and I think Scott is a strong Red Ranger (though he is my second-favorite Red Ranger).

I'm voting for Scott because he was a solid character. TJ was a better blue anyways.

I agree.
TJ was a decent Red, but is Space had him as Blue for a full season as opposed to Turbo, where he just took over Tommy's role.

Scott was Red all the way through. And he had Military training!

I got in Gear. I went with Scott.

TJ led his team into being baked into a gaint pizza while Scott led his team to victory againist the apocalypse...yeah, Scott wins this one. I like both TJ and Scott, but TJ just wasn't the best Red Ranger.

Both had a pretty hard time, but I'm gonna have to give this to Scott.

Scott

Scott gets my vote.

I think TJ's main problem is that he was just a placeholder Red Ranger. Just someone, storywise, to bridge the gap of story between Tommy leaving and Andros coming in. That's how it felt to me, anyway.

Except he wasn't.
Tanya was a placeholder character.