Thanks for all of the suggestions everyone! After doing some research on everyone's suggestions I think I got a pretty good idea of what I want to watch next.

Kuuga, Agito, Ryuki, First 28 eps of Hibiki, Kabuto, Den-O, W, OOO, Fourze, Gaim, and then Ex-Aid. I would recommend Black given it carries the essence and core concepts of a Kamen Rider but if it is too old for your taste start with Kuuga.

So I'm currently watching Fourze around episode 26 currently it seems kinda boring. Does the show start taking off in the second half or should I just give the series up?

I say give a few more eps a chance and if it does not float your boat, GET TO DA CHOPPA.

Well, what kind of stuff do you like? Do you prefer action, suspense, mystery, sci-fi, horror, comedy - what's your preference? What are your fave Sentai / Ultra shows?

(yes, I said this a page ago for the OP - but, trust me - it'll help!)