Gaim, of course. :D

I'm waiting until it ends to make a call on that.

Makes sense. I picked Gaim because it has depth. There are consequences, and there are morals other than black bad and white good. They have characters who aren't just one direction, but instead have multiple parts to their personality. Also, the suckish fight scenes make sense in hindsight, at least in the beginning. They're inexperienced teens who aren't masters in martial arts like Takatora (I assume) or Yoko.

Oh, I understand why. I like it a lot too, but the story could flop near the end. It probably won't, but there is always a chance.

I don't know, but I have faith in the Urobutcher.

I do too, but like I said there's always a chance. I've seen shows start off good, then get bad near the end.

While I would of picked Gaim, W for me is just better.