I love that song so much. Seeing it fully animated was amazing~

I'm glad they didn't give a definitive yes or no concerning Pinkie's relation, but even if it was a "No," I'm sure the Apples would be willing to accept her anyway.

And that eagle gag. I loved it :lol

Agreed~

Seriously dude. I was like "I know we've dealt with eternal night, eternal chaos, parasitical enslavement, and dictators who use dark magic...but that was really dark for this show!"

This episode just hit all the right notes with me, surprisingly difficult for an episode missing Rarity :lol

And if it's any consolation, the duck survived, at least :p

Yeah. I think it's because it didn't rely on something like being entered into a comic book, or bat transformations. It went back to the season one thing of just having a conflict, and taking that opportunity to explore the character's personality. (I guess you could just call it a character study.) It's kind of nice to have one of those again.

Really liked this episode, Pinkies duck face moment made me cringe and laugh all at the same time. I feel the moral was strong and all around it was better then some of the stinkers in S3. ^^ x

Didn't we have one last week with Rarity Takes Manehattan?
It was a character study of Rarity and what her core values are.

I'm loving Pinkie Apple Pie enough to consider putting it in my top 10 of the series :lol

'Twas a really good episode. Season 4 seems to be doing surprisingly well. I thought I'd exhausted my pony fandom but they keep churning out good ones. :D

You wouldn't leave us, would you~?

I know, I just forgot about it for a second. :lol

Don't you dare leave.

(On a separate note. I think it's really stupid how so many people saw Alicorn Twilight, and just gave up. As if forgetting the previous two seasons even existed.)

Not yet. :D Hope to find some spark in it, but the show is doing a good job. :D