|
Community Links |
Members List |
Search Forums |
Advanced Search |
Go to Page... |
![]() |
I can forgive Die for not noticing it, but I can't believe no one has mentioned the biggest thing to happen in this episode: we got the first appearance of Tsurugi's pronunciation of Kagami's name. It'll get more exaggerated as we go on, but it started here.
So, one thing I'll say about the Hiyori reveal is that it doesn't feel like a retcon or something that the writer threw in out of nowhere. It does fit with a lot of the earlier interactions between Tendou and Hiyori and why Tendou was so insistent on forcing his way into this otherwise random girl's life. It also recontextualizes the scene from a few episodes back where Kagami's dad vaguely threatens Tendou's little sister - he was talking about Hiyori, not Juka. So I actually like the twist in how it makes sense when retroactively applied to the rest of the series. The big issue I have is with the execution, especially when we get to the later stuff with the Tendou in the Iron Mask. I don't doubt that this twist was planned from the start, but the timing and execution are things that I have some real concerns with. So, as was spoiled earlier, Yui Satonaka, aka Hiyori, got sick and couldn't continue working on the show full-time (you may have noticed that she's been largely or entirely absent from a lot of recent episodes). I'm sure that the Worm reveal was planned for some point, but I don't know if it was supposed to happen now or later. All the stuff with Tendou-2, though, definitely feels like it was crammed into the episode because the show needed to a) act while Hiyori was still available and b) find a mechanism to write her out. |
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Well sorry you still don't like the reveal. It fits though, with the shape shifting Worms replacing people and the like. Still it seems pretty obvious that this was planned. You are for whatever reason, enjoying the things about this show that I dislike and disliking that things that I like. This show is just that weird I guess.
|
Quote:
For the record, I never thought the reveal that Hiyori and Tendou were related was unplanned or a retcon. (I did think it was something that was just in the movie at first, though.) This show's way too smart and intricate to just suddenly decide something this major. I would not doubt for a second that it was in the initial pitch document or series bible. What I'd argue is that it's an unnecessary element, and one that arrives later in the series than I'd enjoy. If this happened around episode 15 or 20, I'd be a little more receptive to it. Here, at 32, it feels like the relationships between the characters had progressed so much further than Secret Siblings as an idea, gotten so much deeper than Tendou Has To Kill Kagami To Protect Hiyori's Secret. (Which, I see what the show is going for emotionally with that, highlighting Tendou's unshackled commitment to Hiyori, but it comes off like Tendou hasn't listened to a word Kagami said for the last two episodes. Kagami was specifically the one who said that Not All Worms deserve to die. It's another moment in this one where I can't understand why people are behaving the way they are.) It... I think it flattens out the uniqueness of Tendou and Hiyori's bond, and that bums me out. Also, I think my feelings about Tendou/Hiyori (do not like) are getting a little tangled up with Hiyori/Worm (pretty into, didn't love how the show handled the fallout) as far as how I'm communicating my feelings about this episode. There are two reveals, and it's really the Secret Siblings one that I regret the show pursuing. |
Quote:
Like, I feel like this episode would've been better served as two episodes? An episode that's more directly about Hiyori being a Worm would've felt like the show was taking that change seriously, while a following episode that let Tendou react as her brother would've been... I mean, I still wouldn't be in favor of it as a story, but I think it would've felt more organic (and less intrusive) than it did here. |
Quote:
How he would react to finding out the terrible truth is something that makes Kagami hesitate to tell him, which puts him in a similar situation to Tendo who holds the truth about Hiyori. It's a difficult problem. If the truth is so terrible, does that justify keeping it a secret from someone or lying to them, or does that just allow them to live in false happiness? Does it make the humans any different from the Worms? Maybe Tsurugi, who is if nothing else honest, is more human that most actual humans which is why Kagami feels a connection with him. Quote:
Quote:
I think all the nuance of their friendship is still there and the new revelations about Hiyori are just as important to Hiyori's own story as Tendo's. You wanted to see more progress for Hiyori's arc following their adventure in Area X and that's what's happening here. With this new information, she has gone back to that place in search of answers that should hopefully be more clear to her now. The other Souji is important to her destiny. Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
Quote:
I'd like to talk about how Tendou responds to Kagami in this episode. If Tendou proclaims to kill any beings to protect Hiyori, because of Kagami knowing that she's alive (Tendou faking her death so that she won't be targeted by others), so that means Tendou won't allow anyone to know or interact with Hiyori other than him? How would Hiyori be able to live properly this way, with Tendou wanting Hiyori to live as Hiyori (I know what that means, he wants for Hiyori to live as Hiyori, not as a monstrous Worm)? This is overprotective taken to the extremes. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
For her getting a psychic Find My Friend ping and discovering Another Tendou... it's a lot for one episode. They are hitting Hiyori with being a Worm, finding out her terrible origins, discovering Tendou is her brother, and then still having her wander off to Area X (a hard right after Area Sundown) to meet Another Tendou. That's a lot! I think all of that stuff needed more room to breathe. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
And her running off because Worm Widow is telling her They're All Going To Laugh At You... I mean, if we're going to refer to that as Hiyori being in control of her story, we have lowered the bar pretty low. The problem for me with both of those examples are that it becomes more about other people's agendas, other plots. Worm Widow's scene is about her manipulating Hiyori, not Hiyori responding to manipulation. (It's also under a minute long, so let's keep that in mind.) Hiyori going to see Another Tendou at the end isn't some huge decision, it's a weird plot thing that happens because of a psychic phenomenon. Quote:
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:39 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:39 AM.
|