I actually hated Yuuki at first. Doesn't help that she was as bad as the Samurai actors during the start of the series.
Though, I did grow to like her, but then her actions just kept getting more and more..."Out there" as the series progressed, and I started disliking her again.

Nope. I hated Gemini and Evil Yuuki. It seemed like a cop out, rather than have Yuuki actually, you know, do something and press the switch, all they had to do was force her to press it and she just happened to get the switch that would summon an evil clone of her.
I liked Fourze, but that story arc pissed me off.

Really? Maybe I'm jus a big Fourze Fanboy. Nothing really annoyed me on the show. I was a little bothered about the touchy feely way he came back to life after Ryuusei FiveFingerDeathPunched his chest, but that was about it. I liked Libra, Leo, Virgo. Never saw the Virgo plottwist coming, I can tell you that. Or Tachibanana. Fourze is one of those series' I wish could have a second season.

I think Shotaro from W is my favorite character.
He is always trying so hard to be hard boiled and badass like Sokichi Narumi, and even though everyone keeps telling him that he'll never be that cool, he tries.

plus, he's unflinching in his efforts to protect Phillip and fight the Dopants, even in cases where he is clearly out matched.

I liked that arc, if only for the fact that it reminded me so much of a Persona game.

I disliked the Gemini arc because of all the dropped story potential. Aquarius essentially got what I wished Yuuki got. A Horoscope that isn't just "Kill kill evil evil", someone attempting to do good but succumbing to evil. If Yuuki had gotten that, it would've been a lot deeper and the resolution a lot more emotional.
And I'm not asking for a rehash of the Aquarius story arc. Just something more than "Gamou's marrying the evil twin. lolk."

Loved the Virgo plot, loved Tachibana, loved Libra (Though his random fanatic obsession towards Gamou at the end did come out of nowhere. Would've preferred if he kept his remorseful ways. He and Leo got no form of redemption, which sucks).

gemini...Yuuki in that black dress...I'm good...

Momotaros! A fine line is drawn between rebel bad ass and comic relief with him. Not too many fictional characters get to be both. The charm of a monster that looks like Satan that turns into a super hero and fights other monsters never gets old to me. I can also relate to being short tempered and being called an idiot by my peers like him.

Kisaragi Gentaro because Fourze is awesome!

I'll go with Gai Yuki/Black Condor from Jetman, because not only is an everlasting fountain of cool, not only did he gut-punch Ryu whenever Ryu needed to have his brain rebooted (or just needed to be punched, really) but because he's so cool he gets heavenly hall passes from God hi--uh, Herself due to being awesome at poker. :)

We currently have 16 entries!