[Shin Henshin]

Quote:

Originally Posted by guncannon109

It definitely split me alright.

The biggest thing for me is deciding whether Homura kidnapping Madoka and turning into the devil at the very end was in character for her or not.

See while it was very drastic, I see it as Homura snapping and discovering that doing that would be the only way to ensure that Madoka's life would never be endangered again. It's a happy ending seeing as all the girls are either given a chance at a normal life or a second chance at it in Sayaka's and Nagisa's case, but it's an amazingly dark and twisted one given what it took to get to that point.