[SPLIT LIP]

Quote:

Originally Posted by MaskedRiderAsakura

In response to the first sentence: of course. That's the whole reason he was given a deck in the first place.

That doesn't make it a good reason.

He was a monster of the week who could talk. That's about it.

Quote:

Not only that but outside of killing he served as a moral test for Ryuki and Knight, as practically every other character in the series does.

He could've been taht and had any kind of personality.

Quote:

Because Ren lacks the conviction to kill, you could almost say he gathers inspiration from Ouja.

No, you really couldn't.

Quote:

He makes note of this saying that perhaps he needs to become like Asakura in order to fulfill his wish.

That's not inspiration. That's Ren struggling over his want to win the game, but his inability to be a murderer.

And it's still not a personality for Ouja.

Quote:

Not only that but Asakura serves as a point to Shinji that even the lowest form of human being is worth keeping alive, as shown In the story arc where Asakura 'saves' the girl

They could've done that and gave him some kind of personality or character.

Quote:

(and the series leaves it ambiguous as to whether Asakura is really as heartless as he's portrayed to be at this point).

It really doesn't. At all. He's just a psycho.

Quote:

After all that's what the ideal villain IS:

No, absolutely not.

That's HALF of an ideal villain. The other half is being a convincing villain. Someone where, even if we don't agree with their motives, we can see that they have motives.

Asakura HAS no motives. Since you compare him to the Joker below, let's roll with that. The Joker is utterly insane, and unpredictable. It's unknown exactly what he'll do everytime he goes on a rampage, if he'll blindly murder or just fuck with everyone. He derives immense pleasure and amusement from the things he does, but also becomes aggressively violent at the drop of a hat. His mood swings are dangerous, bt also endearing. It's hard not to laugh when he tells someone not to speak, asks them a question, then hits them for answering. He's like a cartoon character in a world of regular people, except he's not the bouncy, bright kind. More like the demented kind. Hell, Joker's probably the single worst kind of human being in the world. He's a murderer, a sadist, a bully, a racist, and has done truely revolting things... and yet you still like him and even feel bad for him sometimes. THAT is what an ideal villain is.

Asakura is EXCEEDINGLY predictable and one-track, and is not endearing at all. There's no surprises or intrigue with him. He hurts people, big whoop. he's not funny, he's not scary. He doesn't instill fear or unrest in everyone. He hangs around with the other riders and nobody cares. I still remember that immensely moronic scene where the big four of Ryuki got together and Kitaoka held a vote on wether Shinji was an idiot, to which everyone voted yes, even Ouja. Like he was a regular guy, joking around with his buds. This actually WOULD be reminiscent of Joker-style antics, except everyone else apprently forgot he was an unrepentant killer and acted like he was a normal dude. Even the characters find him utterly boring. There's nothing TO him. He has NO personality. "I want to hurt people" is not a personality.

Quote:

Shinji and Asakura have a very Batman/Joker relationship going on.

Not even close. batman and Joker's relationship is far too complicated to even be compared.

Joker and Batman are damn-near obsessed with eachother, Joker more than Batman. Anytime Joker escapes, Batman shifts all focus on him, and almost everything Joker does, it's to get pointy-ears' attention. He gets depressed or in denial when Batman is presumed dead, and devises huge elaborate schemes to confront him with. And true to form, even THIS is unpredictable to everyone but him. One moment Joker can be trying his hardest to muder Batman, the next he defends him. Batman, on the other hand, only wants Joker jailed. Joker tests Batman so much, more than once Batman has admitted to fantasising about killing Joker. THAT is how much Joker infuriates Batman.

Shinji and Asakura... are practically non existent in comprarrison. Shinji has no real opinion of Asakura, and inconsistently shifts focus on and off him. Asakura barely knows Shinji exists, and doesn't really care. Ren is more of a nemesis to Asakura than Sinji.

Joker tests Batman's will against killing. Asakura tests Shinji's will to stop the fighting. The difference is that Batman's goal is accomplishable.
Shinji's goal, however, is dead on arrival. That's the point. It's pointless to believe that needs to be tested. That's like one guy's goal being to blow up the sun with his thoughts, and another guy hellbent on breaking his concentration, as if the first guy's goal isn't absurd enough.

So even as a foil, Ouja fials.

Quote:

And his rivalry with Kitaoka was always there. It was usually just obscured by the odd newbie Rider jumping in and making things more complicated and by the fact that Kitaoka and Asakura fights were always either inconclusive or interrupted. There were more Ouja and Zolda clashes than you give credit for. Whenever it was just the main four though, Ouja and Zolda were ALWAYS getting under each other's skins.

This is partly true. This was easily the highlight of Ouja's character, and the culmination of this plot thread in the final episode was MASTERFULLY pulled off.

However, you give it FAR too much credit, and this is where my idea of Ouja being MORE infrequent would've helped. Because the rivalry was spread so thin, it seemed like it wasn't as important to the characters. Had teh series been shorter, and Ouja appeared less, these moments would've seemed MORE important.

Quote:

To say Ouja was just thrown in whenever a Rider needed to be killed off is just false.

Maybe, but it's not far off.

Asakura never did anything besides kill people. It may not have been his purpose, but it's what he ultimately ended up doing. I mean, he never even DID anything by himself. Or when he did, it was just running from cops and getting mad. It was clear that they had no idea what to do with him when all of his down time was the same old shit of him running and fuming. Again, since you brought up Joker, when HE is on downtime, it's usually doing something utterly unpredictable, like killing a donut shop owner, or robbing stores for money. Which IS unpredicatble for the Joker, since he's not usually so petty for cash, but money is a humanizing aspect that reinforces that he does still succumb to the problems of normal humans and IS a human, instead of some unrealistic thing. Asakura is not human. He never suffers from human problems. The interesting thing about Joker-like characters is how their superhuman personalities react to human problems. What Joker's hungry or needs money, he steal it, and his character makes this barbaric act amusing or insightful in HOW he does it, something Asakura never does. Asakura does not react. He only acts, and acting does tell us as much as reacting.

Quote:

He was literally the standard, and at the same time, the example of what a Rider should and shouldn't be.

Not even close, and I cannot fathom how you came to this point. Unless you mean riders within the context of Ryuki, but even still...

This is where it becomes really hard to not spoil Ryuki, but this ties in with the entire plot of Ryuki being NONSENSE. The rider battle makes no sense, and the point is never explained. Ryuki has probably the worst main plot of any rider series ever, because it is complete nonsense. Thus, what Ouja represents is hard to pin down, since it's not clear what the fighting accomplished. It gave the winner power, but we don't know how. It gave Yui's brother the ability to save her... but we're not told how or why he couldn't just do it himself. If he created the game, why didn't he use that power to save her instead of making some elaborate nonsense?