[SanoBaron]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Den-O

I freely admit to owning All-Star Batman & Robin in Absolute Slipcover Hardcover edition I absolutely loved that over the top ridiculousness of that book. Even though I Know Miller never meant it as parody that's certainly the way it reads making it very very enjoyable. Authorial intent be damned!

I am willing to admit also that I find Year One to be immensely enjoyable for what it is. When you start adding layers of meaningless brutality & darkness on top of things I get miffed. But Year One struck a very good balance between some of Miller's more dark tendencies but with a silver lining of hope and heroism that I can still appreciate.

yeah, Year One is probably one of Miller's better works, to say the least.

I highly enjoy it, and it's nice to see Gotham as more of a darker place than normal. my only problem with it really is Celina's design. I feel it's too much in the opposite direction of the "pretty cat lover" and just goes a bit too far on the butch side.