[Fish Sandwich]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Castellan Zilla

Maybe, but hiding behind the opinion argument is a poor one. You can look at something critically and acknowledge how terrible it is, while still enjoying it.

I'm not hiding behind it. I just said I think Kiva is the worst Heisei show and that I also really enjoy it. You make a good point. I agree with that notion, but the problem is that "objective" analysis of something's quality inevitably still comes back down to opinion.

For example, I think Gaim is one of the worse Rider shows I've seen because it had a sloppily executed story that couldn't seem to get its messages straight and really hit or miss characterization. There's a ton going for it, it's well directed, the acting's great, and it knew how to keep the tension up, but it failed at things I personally consider fundamental and because of that it's hard for me to just call it "great".

Wizard is another show I consider less good than my opinion of it suggests. I think in most respects it's basically okay, but it clicked with me and I enjoyed it a lot.

Basically enjoying something is an opinion, and thinking something is good is ALSO an opinion. It goes without saying that stuff has flaws, it's just a matter of how much the good points balance it out for you.