[Sh Ranger]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Zolda

Bruuuhhh... I already refuted how completely wrong almost all your points were in the same exact post, and I refuted them not only with timestamps but also with screenshots. Almost all your points were based on faulty reasoning, straw man arguments, or just being plain wrong. If faulty reasoning, straw man arguments, or just being plain wrong were how you based your arguments on, then I saw no reason to continue the debate. I saw no reason to continue the debate against someone who clearly had no intention of using critical thinking, logic, rationality, and common sense at all. I saw no reason to continue the debate against someone whose intention was clearly to misunderstand reality.

Hmm, I see. Well, thanks for clearing that up. Spares me the waste of time of continuing a debate against someone who doesn't take his opponent seriously.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Zolda

If being a good heroine is irrelevant, then KR Gotchard will also be irrelevant.

You have no historical basis for this. As far as I can recall, Gotchard is the only season with a co-protagonist in place of an official heroine and so far it has been successful. I see no reason why that would change in the future.

Not sure if I'll bother indulging your arguments again, so for now, I'll just leave you with some profound advice:

If you're going to ask questions and decline answers, at least try answering those questions on your own to reach a conclusion where you were wrong instead of "right". That's what critical thinking really means.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mesnick

But in the memories with kid Shouma there are no dates indicated. The only thing we can take as a starting point is that Hanto?s mother was kidnapped 18 years ago. If we accept that the Wolf Granute from the flashback is not Shouma, but another patient, and the flashback itself is a memory of the red Gavv, then Shouma does not have to age at all. This, by the way, is partly supported by the fact that the flashback about Hanto?s mother at the factory did not bring a headache, unlike the memory about her abduction.

Exactly. If something is wrong in the execution, then there's likely something wrong with the theory. Like Hanto, we should go back through the events and find the narrative that makes sense.