[ZeoRangerV]

Davison's actually my least favourite Doctor. He had some decent stories but his Doctor is too "safe"/bland and every companion he had was either annoying, bland or both. Its only really on the recent audios I've taken a liking to him.

Caves of Androzani however is one of, if not the best regeneration stories.

[Sentai]

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZeoRangerV

Davison's actually my least favourite Doctor. He had some decent stories but his Doctor is too "safe"/bland and every companion he had was either annoying, bland or both. Its only really on the recent audios I've taken a liking to him.

Caves of Androzani however is one of, if not the best regeneration stories.

He followed Baker, though. They really couldn't take him more into left field after that portrayal, they could only make him more a straight man.

[Thessair]

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZeoRangerV

Davison's actually my least favourite Doctor. He had some decent stories but his Doctor is too "safe"/bland and every companion he had was either annoying, bland or both. Its only really on the recent audios I've taken a liking to him.

Caves of Androzani however is one of, if not the best regeneration stories.

I thought I was the only person who ranked Davison at the bottom of the list. He seems to be the favorite Doctor for so many...

[ZeoRangerV]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sentai

He followed Baker, though. They really couldn't take him more into left field after that portrayal, they could only make him more a straight man.

And they took it to the lengths that he was a dull guy who's main quirks were he liked cricket and wore a leak. It didn't make for a very good Doctor.

[Sentai]

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZeoRangerV

And they took it to the lengths that he was a dull guy who's main quirks were he liked cricket and wore a leak. It didn't make for a very good Doctor.

Celery :P But I see your point.

[ZeoRangerV]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sentai

Celery :P But I see your point.

My forgetfulness when it comes to his decorative vegetable shows how little I care for him

If I had to rank Doctors, it would probably go:

Pertwee
McCoy
Tom Baker
McGann
Eccleston
Smith
Troughton
Hartnell
Colin Baker
Tennant
Davison

[AkibaSilver]

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZeoRangerV

My forgetfulness when it comes to his decorative vegetable shows how little I care for him

If I had to rank Doctors, it would probably go:

Pertwee
McCoy
Tom Baker
McGann
Eccleston
Smith
Troughton
Hartnell
Colin Baker
Tennant
Davison

If we're doing this:
McGann
Smith
Ecclestone
T. Baker
Troughton
C. Baker
Tennant
Hartnell
Pertwee
Davison

Bear in mind two things: a) This is a very close list. Otherwise, I'd think bad of Tennant, and that is not a good thing!
b) I'm not including McCoy because my only experience with him is 10 minutes of the movie and my documentary in Trial of A Time Lord (which is him raising his eyebrows and clkimbing down a cliff).

Also, that poster looks amazing. I really wish we'd get a 5" Hurt figure.

[ZeoRangerV]

While I question you having Pertwee down so low (this is meant in jest), its great to see someone rating McGann so highly. He's a superb Doctor.

[AkibaSilver]

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZeoRangerV

While I question you having Pertwee down so low (this is meant in jest), its great to see someone rating McGann so highly. He's a superb Doctor.

I might rate him higher, but at current I've seen him in The Claws of Axos and The Five Doctors, and he hasn't really stood out to me. He just seems too strict and close-minded, not to mention very stubborn.

[AkibaSilver]

So, I picked up the new Doctor Who Magazine today. Pretty good issue, and the new comic seems really good. Can't wait for 'Light and the End'.