[ZeoRangerV]

I'm just sad that Radio Times ended up ignoring the troll votes. For a while Adric and Mel were winning

[Locke]

Just finished Foboss or however that's spelt, the ending was a tad rushed, sorta felt like they couldn't decide on a single ending so they used several. The rest of the episode was fun though, much better than the Horror of Glam Rock which has been the worst episode so far.

[ComicGuy89]

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZeoRangerV

I'm just sad that Radio Times ended up ignoring the troll votes. For a while Adric and Mel were winning

Was Mel that unpopular?

[ZeoRangerV]

Quote:

Originally Posted by ComicGuy89

Was Mel that unpopular?

Oh yes

[ComicGuy89]

Well I'm not big enough of a fan to know.

[Thessair]

Now, I freely admit to having started with the 2005 series, but I went back and watched all of the classic series (including the reconstructions) and have a tremendous love for it. Rose was the first companion I ever saw, and she's one of my least favorites. To be honest, most of the new series companions I find annoying.

Yet, for some reason, I love Mel and I don't mind Adric. I think part of that is hearing how awful they were prior to watching them and then finding they weren't as terrible as advertised. (Adric, I think, gets a particularly bad rap but he acts just like most of the really smart young people I've known in my life.) But, sadly, I know that most of my Who tastes don't align with the general consensus. I do have to acknowledge the fact that I didn't watch these as they came out so I can't really understand some of the 'whys' behind the opinions of long-time fans as I didn't grow up with it.

[Sentai]

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZeoRangerV

So much predictable bias and ignorance in this article.

Radio Times: Doctor Who 50th anniversary: 5 reasons why Rose Tyler is the show's best companion ever

So I guess Elizabeth Sladin was never in Doctor Who then

[WhiteRanger]

a new video interview with moffet http://www.kasterborous.com/2013/11/...-doctor-video/

[Locke]

Just finished 'no more lies' my least favourite 8th adventure, it started in the middle, never provided context and I spent the majority of the episode wondering if I skipped an episode by accident.

Just finished the Human Resources two parter, SO GOOD! Gonna have to buy the second season now.

[Sentai]

Had a question. According to that minisode, the eight Doctor becomes John Hurt's War Doctor. So.. does that make War 9th, Eccleson 10th, Tennant 11, and Smith 12?