[Sh Ranger]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Zolda

To me, Agito is the superior version of Faiz, or rather, Faiz it the watered down version of Agito, haha.

Strong disagree!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Zolda

That quoted paragraph obviously contain typos that resulted in the wrong link and user name. No need to reply to a post that contain a wrongly attributed quote, since you knew you never said that quoted paragraph in the first place. I've just corrected that post. Not sure how I pasted the wrong link and user name, haha.

And why are you annoyed with me calling the Granute of the week in episodes 17-18 the (bird?) Granute? I call it the (bird?) Granute due to it's hideous, ugly appearance, haha. Perhaps the designers from Plex intended for the Granutes of the week to be very hideous and ugly. I'm fine with the designs of the Stomach family members, though.

If I was limited to replying to only the posts addressed to me, then my post count would only be a tiny fraction of what it is now.

You typing out "the Granute of the week in episodes 17-18" makes me think that you're actively trying to call him anything but his actual name. "(bird?) Granute" is repetitive to have to read over and over again and doesn't even imply anything about his physical appearance other than maybe looking like a bird. It's unnecessary.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Zolda

Your statement about me dismissing the nurturing trait that I value in heroines is one of the most fatal forms of faulty logic/reasoning called a straw man argument. What actually happens: I've never dismissed it at all. Sachika nurturing trait is completely superficial. It's an illusion. Caking exists not because of Sachika's nurturing trait, but because Shouma is a dysfunctional 25(!) or 28(!) year-old man who can't even find a job for himself. If Shouma can find a job and make an income for himself, then Sachika would not need to give him jobs, and she'd be pretty much irrelevant and would be relegated to a recurring minor character.

You make it sound like getting a job is easy, regardless of Granute super strength. There's no point talking about a hypothetical character who isn't socially awkward (almost like he's been locked away from the outside world or something, oh wait, he was), as then we wouldn't be talking about Shouma anymore. This is the setting and characters we've got, so this is what I'm concerned with. Even if Shouma could get a job, that wouldn't bring him happiness. Sachika's main role is to give Shouma happiness, not just jobs. So Sachika is essential for Caking's creation.

Regarding Shouma's age, I'm open to the suggestion that he might be slightly older than Chinen, but only slightly, most likely early 20s. 25-28 would be excessive, as that would make him older than 23 year-old Hanto. Unless we consider differences in longevity between humans and Granutes. How old is an old Granute anyway?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Zolda

You would've gladly argued against my points about Mai from KR Gaim in KR Gotchard's thread? Bruuuhhh, I already refuted virtually all your wrong points with timestamps and screenshots. No need to repeat it.

You don't get to call my points wrong simply by presenting your argument and then immediately shutting down the debate:

"Ah, I've just remembered that this is Gochard's thread, so this should be my last post talking about Gaim here, haha."

The lawyer doesn't get to shut down the prosecutor. The case is open. Like I said, I'm willing to present my counterargument, but I'm not interested in debating for the sake of being right. It needs to be constructive and right now, it's clear that you don't want your essay to be challenged. So I won't, but I assure you that I can. And if you call my bluff, then I will.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Zolda

Pretty much the opposite, I actually expected you to agree with Hina and Kohana being Riders. Hina and Kohana being Riders would've definitely hampered their main function as heroines.

Kohana is a Singularity Point, which makes her eligible to become a Rider in Den-O's setting. All she'd need is a Driver and a contract with an Imagin.

Hina could've become Birth after Date went to get his brain surgery, but Gotou took over the role instead. Honestly, I think she would've been a great Birth.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Zolda

Let's say hello to Rinne Kudou whose main role as Gotchard's heroine was very very very bad.

Yeah, let's say hello to Kudo Rinne who's intentionally not supposed to be a good heroine since her main role is officially Gotchard's co-protagonist according to Producer Minato. We've already been through this. Why are you still judging her based on irrelevant criteria?