Integration

Fish Sandwich · 02-14-2017, 10:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Deepsea

http://cannibal-sarracenian.tumblr.com/post/98738185896/redemptive-reading-of-gaims-ending-what-if-it

What do you guys think of this analysis of the ending of Gaim?

Hey, I already asked that exact question like 30 pages ago!

Which means I can just recycle my opinion:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fish Sandwich

I disagree with the fundamental points being presented, but that post inadvertently hits on a lot of my big criticisms of Gaim in a way that's a bit more elegant that I usually am.

Basically, I think that post is giving the crappy writing in Gaim's ending WAY too much credit. It basically ignores huge parts of what Gaim was actually about to arrive at a conclusion that, while sounding convincing enough on its own merits, doesn't really gel with the series as a whole.

02-14-2017, 10:00 AM	#4352
Fish Sandwich The Immortal King Tasty Join Date: Jan 2012 Location: Every diner you've ever been to. Posts: 4,060	Quote: Originally Posted by Deepsea http://cannibal-sarracenian.tumblr.com/post/98738185896/redemptive-reading-of-gaims-ending-what-if-it What do you guys think of this analysis of the ending of Gaim? Hey, I already asked that exact question like 30 pages ago! Which means I can just recycle my opinion: Quote: Originally Posted by Fish Sandwich I disagree with the fundamental points being presented, but that post inadvertently hits on a lot of my big criticisms of Gaim in a way that's a bit more elegant that I usually am. Basically, I think that post is giving the crappy writing in Gaim's ending WAY too much credit. It basically ignores huge parts of what Gaim was actually about to arrive at a conclusion that, while sounding convincing enough on its own merits, doesn't really gel with the series as a whole. __________________